How This Story Ends

The desk by the south-facing window
Manitoba, Canada
July 20, 2009

My dear American varmint,

The beginning of this story is right in the middle of things. Through the wardrobe, into the magical frozen wasteland. Welcome to Canada, to a small town of three streets by four surrounded by hidden creeks and a montage of hills and plains. Green in spring, golden in fall, fallow black-and-white in winter’s stark exposure.

There’s so little time on this earth; so much to say. I’ll see little of you in this life, so these letters will have to do.

There’s a mystery here amid the change and silence. So, let me finish the picture I began to sketch.

Many of the essays I write here are in fact letters to faraway friends, most often my Texan varmint of a writing partner. They’re illustrations of the life that exists here on the Canadian prairies — an older way of life, a beautiful and largely forgotten place that predates the cultural and economic shifts of urbanization and industrial farming. Here, we are still family, with our feet and history planted in the ploughed earth.

In 2010, I was approached by a small publishing startup about doing a creative nonfiction book. I collected, rewrote, expanded upon, and thought long and hard about how to make these various seasonal ramblings into a bigger picture. They begin here in my prairie. But where should they conclude? Like the ocean, the prairie goes on forever.

As it turned out, it didn’t matter right then. The small press owner had no stable direction, and shortly after I signed, the internal dynamics became toxic. I cancelled my contract as circumspectly as possible. The owner cancelled the rest of the relationship when I found her bullying other writers and (rather firmly) suggested she stick to standard critique etiquette. Her departure was both hilariously melodramatic and quite a pleasant change.

And I thought that was how the story ended. Life went on the same as it has, and the manuscript sat quietly in my files. Creative nonfiction, after all, isn’t fiction. It draws on actual life events. How can one write an ending that hasn’t happened?

But now it has.

For he says, “At the acceptable time…”

2 Cor. 6:2

We’re moving away.

We never planned to. When we got here, Dave said it was the last time and we were staying here forever. But for some very strong reasons, eventually he changed his mind. And after a year of stalling and digging my heels in, I changed mine with him.

So we go. Out of the prairie and into a more suburban setting. Out of the solitude (also known, on bad days, as isolation) and into a different kind of closeness, one I’m not sure I’ll be comfortable with.

There, it’s the closeness of unknown neighbours who may have opinions about our rather creative lifestyle. It’s the invisible cords of greater regulation and restriction.

Here, it’s the closeness of family, with all its headaches and treasures. The cords are blood ties and heartstrings.

I have lain down and cried several times. My youngest child was born in this house. We’ve put so much of our time together into it, made it over in ways that speak silently of our relationships and the gifts of others.

The antique floor-to-ceiling newel posts given me by my mother-in-law.

The ceramic tile I laid with my daughters and son, a skill taught me by my father and passed on to my children.

The windows my husband bought me because I find them beautiful.

The church full of people I’ve known literally all my life, many of whom I’m obscurely related to going back five generations. Our ancestors settled here together, broke sod together, broke bread together. The weave is invisible and immeasurable.

I don’t know how to write this ending, except in the belief that it isn’t one. It’s another beginning.

When I left here, it was with no wish to return or ever to claim my heritage. Growing up here was difficult and traumatic. It left me bitter. But like other things that I never thought would heal, that too is healed over now by the surgically precise guidance of an unseen hand.

I trust that hand. It writes a bigger story than I can.

You have taken account of my wanderings;
Put my tears in Your bottle.
Are they not in Your book?

Psalm 56:8

Yesterday, we told our church. I cried. My lifelong neighbours cried. I was embraced and prayed for. There was grief and shock and maybe a bit of denial on all sides. I write this down because I want to remember, in time to come, how different it was from the last church we left. A church full of empty politics and knives designed to sever one’s backbone.

Back then, the phone never rang once. No regrets were given, not even among those few who stayed semi-casually in touch. “Good riddance,” the rumour mill of that other town echoed back to us. And this gem of a quote: “I don’t care about them, but I miss their children.”

“How do you two manage to keep smiling?” a friend on the sidelines asked us back then.

“Oh… we don’t. We shed our tears at home,” my husband answered.

So we went, broken; we went home.

And here my home was, waiting to heal so many, many aching wounds.

We’ll never quite leave. I’ll always be from here, where my great-great grandfather built a manor house and planted an orchard. Where a creek winds down between pasture hills under oak-scented leaves and sunshine. Where family may hurt each other, but they don’t leave it on those terms. There’s always coming back and making better.

I get it now. I know where I’m from.

I’m from here, and forever, where a good and gracious God will make a final healing and a final homecoming. In this world, all things change and fall to dust. The old schoolhouse my father attended has burned down. The church where my ancestors are buried is abandoned. The people I remember, pass on. There are would-be publishers taking out their personal issues on the business and churches imagining their internal politics are religion. It’s all a big game where the fleeting, poisonous butterfly of ego rules the day.

All is vanity. There’s nothing new under the sun.

But still the grain fields ripple under a vast and perfect sky, like the last unending amen. And always I will walk them; find me there.


About these ads


  1. I stole this for my facebook wall: “Certainly, it’s no inheritance for our children, not when the whole world will do its best to tell them sin is nothing. They do not need a church which does the same. The reason is simple: where will you go when sin’s power and pain overwhelm you? If not to those who for refuge to Jesus have fled, then where on this earth? If they refuse to understand sin’s forces in the name of neighbourly goodwill, how will grace ever be given?”

    That’s just really good.

  2. Wow, I don’t quite know what to say. I’ll have to begin imagining you against a different backdrop. Blessings to you on your move and your new life forged elsewhere.

    1. Absolutely! In great things, it’s a lot closer to the main highway. If you get lost getting there, we’re declaring an open comedy night themed around your navigation skills. :-D

  3. Dear Cat; this is hard, to leave one’s roots. I have left places many times, but it was hardest to know whether I should leave the town where my husband is buried.

    I knew if I stayed I would always be “Mike’s widow”. I knew if I left few would remember him or us.

    In the end, two things helped me make the decision. One is a painting that hangs on my bedroom wall. I bought it because it had my favorite colors in it and a gate into another place, and it is captioned “My heart is at home in the presence of God”. That meant to me that it didn’t matter where I lived–wherever that was, I could live “at home” in God’s presence.

    The other is an old worship song titled Better is One Day. Somehow that song (the lyrics and perhaps a video link would be available from me for the asking) reminded me that no matter where I put down roots, it will never be as good as one day in the courts of the Lord: and I am guaranteed that, in the end.

    Those thoughts helped me gather my chickies, rise and fly. May God bless you with wings as well.

    1. Thanks, Esther. I see so much of God in this, I think we will fly. But not without the heartache of the transition period — I suppose that’s natural.

      What a profound thing to feel stuck between your beloved’s memory and the outside world’s forgetting of your life together. I can’t express how that moves my heart, except to say that I feel your words deeply.

  4. Oh I do feel for you, but you know what, there’s a lot of it going on? A few people in my virtual world have finally decided this big thing … this dream, these roots, this principle, this burden, this what ever the heck it is … it has to go. In the interests of sanity or family or hope or health or harmony. A lot of great people are on the move. So you’re in good company. And so are they.

    1. Aww, thank you so much. Isn’t it a funny thing how that happens… my brother said some wise words to me on a rare in-person visit recently (we live very far apart). He said, “It doesn’t make sense to say, ‘this was the plan 20 years ago, so we’d better keep doing it.'”

      It’s really true, sometimes the ideas of yesteryear just don’t apply so much anymore.

  5. Dare I say it? I teared up a little as I read this.

    I know the leaving. Done it many times in my life. Sometimes I hated it. Sometimes I couldn’t leave fast enough. I know what’s like to leave beloved houses, perhaps not-so-beloved family, and churches of either kind. But my knowing such leaving and your actually doing it are two different things.

    Lately, God’s been reminding me of seasons: They change. I thought I’d stay at my previous job until I retired. I thought it was the place He’d sent me. He did — just not forever. I thought I’d stay in the house Dad and I rebuilt, because it was perfect for me and such a help to the rest of the family. I did stay — just not forever.

    It’s weird. I understand the changing of seasons, yet I long for certain things from before: a steady paycheck, for instance, or a place of my own. With the greater financial certainty, however, and with the freedom of solitude also came the deadness of a life I once loved but had come to hate.

    Who knows what this uncertain future holds for you and your family? For me and mine? It’s a strange place out here, and no real maps except “one step at a time”.

    1. “with the freedom of solitude also came the deadness of a life I once loved but had come to hate.”

      That’s a big part of it for me. It took me a year longer than Dave, with his commute, to even begin to consider it. Just before Christmas, when I had a week entirely to myself for the first time in my life, I finally found the headspace to realize I’m really not happy anymore with living so isolated. In fact, it’s driving me a little bit crazy.

      It was excellent for raising younger children, and I wouldn’t have it any other way for that, but our oldest is just about in flight… everything is certainly changing its season.

    1. Same thing as before, but without the 2-hour round trip commute attached to his 12-hour shifts that alternate days and nights.

      And without the huge, huge house refurbishing project attached to the commute and the shift work. We’re trading off size for newer and in very good upkeep.

  6. I’ve never had a home such as you describe: I can’t claim to be able to understand or empathise, but it sounds joyfully and excruciatingly bittersweet. Good luck with the move! I hope it all goes smoothly and that the speedbumps aren’t too sudden. :)

    1. It is bittersweet, and yes, joyful too.

      Here’s to small-as-possible speedbumps! I don’t know how many more 12-15 hour days I can put in getting this house fully finished and ready to go. Dave and I are both physically worn out.

What are your thoughts? (Trouble commenting? Leave the email line blank.)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s